Rabbi’s Weekly Message
Rabbi’s Weekly Message, October 1, 2026
An Age-Old Question, and Two Jewish Answers

Illustration: The Book of Ecclesiastes, opening verses. Credit: tonyevans.org

Illustration: The Book of Ecclesiastes, opening verses. Credit: tonyevans.org
Some questions just don’t get asked at parties. But they are among the most important ones of all.
“If you’re going to die anyway, what’s the point of it all?”
This was already an old question when Judaism was new. Long before Moses, the Epic of Gilgamesh wrestles with the question of what a person ought to do, given the knowledge that death is inevitable.
In that work, the protagonist, Gilgamesh, consoles himself with the thought that he will be famous beyond the limits of his lifetime. He was both wrong and right. In the poem, he says that the walls he erected for his city will grant him undying fame. How ironic: the walls are long crumbled to dust, but the poem remains, and hence, the memory of the wall-builder.
In most of the books of our Bible, the focus is on making this world a better place. But the answer that this focus provides to the existential question of meaning in the face of mortality is seldom stated explicitly. Only near the end of the Biblical process does the issue come up explicitly, and our religion’s fuller answer emerges in post-Biblical times.
One of the strangest books of the Bible is Ecclesiastes, an unconventional work in the genre of “Wisdom Literature”. The book breathes the spirit of our people’s encounter with Hellenism after the conquest of the Near East by Alexander the Great. The speaker of the book, whom we may call “The Convener”, puts the question in a stark form: “Surely the fate of human beings is like that of the animals; the same fate awaits them both: as the one dies, so dies the other. All have the same breath; humans have no advantage over animals. Everything is meaningless. All go to the same place; all come from dust and to dust return. Who knows if the human spirit rises upward and if the spirit of the animal goes down into the earth?” (Eccl. 3: 19-21)
Pretty grim! But that is not The Convener’s last word on the subject. In the last chapter of the book, he returns to this theme with a more affirmative conclusion: “Remember [your Creator] before the silver cord is severed, and the golden bowl is broken; before the pitcher is shattered at the spring, and the wheel broken at the well, and the dust returns to the ground it came from, and the spirit returns to God who gave it.” (Eccle. 12:6-7). Yes, of course, to be human is to be mortal, but our relationship to our Creator adds a fuller dimension to what would otherwise threaten to be absurd. While giving expression to a typically pessimistic catalogue of the deficits of aging, The Convener returns to his earlier meditation of the fate of the human body and the human life-breath. This time, he is no longer agnostic: “Who knows?” In this reiteration of his thinking, he affirms: the human life-breath goes back to God, Who gave it.
That is at least some consolation.
It is also far superior to the Gilgamesh trap, the equation of fame, and only fame, with immortality. Few will build monuments that will endure throughout the ages. Even the monumental statues of Rameses II at Abu Simbel were buried under sand until being rediscovered by 19th-century archaeologists. Few will “write the songs that make the young girls cry”; few will write poems that worshipers or lovers recite from generation to generation. But everyone can aspire to a relationship with God, the grantor of our life-breath.
The Jewish meditation on the meaning of life, given its transitory nature, did not conclude with the closing chapter of Ecclesiastes. Our siddur, the compendium of our prayers that serves as the distillation of rabbinic theology, quotes the morose third chapter of Kohelet and then gives it a surprising turn:
“Master of all worlds! Not upon our merit do we rely in our supplication, but upon Your limitless love. What are we? What is our life?... Our actions, for all their profuseness, are meaningless; the days of our lives, emptiness. Human preeminence over beasts is an allusion when all is seen as futility.
“We, however, are Your people, partners to Your covenant…
“Therefore it is our duty to thank You… How good is our portion, how pleasant our lot, how beautiful our heritage!” (Siddur, early morning prayers)
There we have it: covenant is the answer to the consciousness of death. Your life is bounded, but it is a link in an ongoing chain.
The meaning of your life is not exhausted by its finite nature. You are part of a bigger project, “to repair the world under the sovereignty of The Almighty” (Siddur, the Alenu prayer).
There are other Jewish answers, as well: Heaven, in its many depictions; immortality; resurrection—and all of them, poetry for the soul. For me, these first two answers have special resonance. From the first, we learn that a mortal human can be in relationship with Eternity. From the second, we learn to gauge the meaning of our lives in a framework far longer than one lifespan.
Be part of something grand. Be partners with the Eternal.
“If you’re going to die anyway, what’s the point of it all?”
This was already an old question when Judaism was new. Long before Moses, the Epic of Gilgamesh wrestles with the question of what a person ought to do, given the knowledge that death is inevitable.
In that work, the protagonist, Gilgamesh, consoles himself with the thought that he will be famous beyond the limits of his lifetime. He was both wrong and right. In the poem, he says that the walls he erected for his city will grant him undying fame. How ironic: the walls are long crumbled to dust, but the poem remains, and hence, the memory of the wall-builder.
In most of the books of our Bible, the focus is on making this world a better place. But the answer that this focus provides to the existential question of meaning in the face of mortality is seldom stated explicitly. Only near the end of the Biblical process does the issue come up explicitly, and our religion’s fuller answer emerges in post-Biblical times.
One of the strangest books of the Bible is Ecclesiastes, an unconventional work in the genre of “Wisdom Literature”. The book breathes the spirit of our people’s encounter with Hellenism after the conquest of the Near East by Alexander the Great. The speaker of the book, whom we may call “The Convener”, puts the question in a stark form: “Surely the fate of human beings is like that of the animals; the same fate awaits them both: as the one dies, so dies the other. All have the same breath; humans have no advantage over animals. Everything is meaningless. All go to the same place; all come from dust and to dust return. Who knows if the human spirit rises upward and if the spirit of the animal goes down into the earth?” (Eccl. 3: 19-21)
Pretty grim! But that is not The Convener’s last word on the subject. In the last chapter of the book, he returns to this theme with a more affirmative conclusion: “Remember [your Creator] before the silver cord is severed, and the golden bowl is broken; before the pitcher is shattered at the spring, and the wheel broken at the well, and the dust returns to the ground it came from, and the spirit returns to God who gave it.” (Eccle. 12:6-7). Yes, of course, to be human is to be mortal, but our relationship to our Creator adds a fuller dimension to what would otherwise threaten to be absurd. While giving expression to a typically pessimistic catalogue of the deficits of aging, The Convener returns to his earlier meditation of the fate of the human body and the human life-breath. This time, he is no longer agnostic: “Who knows?” In this reiteration of his thinking, he affirms: the human life-breath goes back to God, Who gave it.
That is at least some consolation.
It is also far superior to the Gilgamesh trap, the equation of fame, and only fame, with immortality. Few will build monuments that will endure throughout the ages. Even the monumental statues of Rameses II at Abu Simbel were buried under sand until being rediscovered by 19th-century archaeologists. Few will “write the songs that make the young girls cry”; few will write poems that worshipers or lovers recite from generation to generation. But everyone can aspire to a relationship with God, the grantor of our life-breath.
The Jewish meditation on the meaning of life, given its transitory nature, did not conclude with the closing chapter of Ecclesiastes. Our siddur, the compendium of our prayers that serves as the distillation of rabbinic theology, quotes the morose third chapter of Kohelet and then gives it a surprising turn:
“Master of all worlds! Not upon our merit do we rely in our supplication, but upon Your limitless love. What are we? What is our life?... Our actions, for all their profuseness, are meaningless; the days of our lives, emptiness. Human preeminence over beasts is an allusion when all is seen as futility.
“We, however, are Your people, partners to Your covenant…
“Therefore it is our duty to thank You… How good is our portion, how pleasant our lot, how beautiful our heritage!” (Siddur, early morning prayers)
There we have it: covenant is the answer to the consciousness of death. Your life is bounded, but it is a link in an ongoing chain.
The meaning of your life is not exhausted by its finite nature. You are part of a bigger project, “to repair the world under the sovereignty of The Almighty” (Siddur, the Alenu prayer).
There are other Jewish answers, as well: Heaven, in its many depictions; immortality; resurrection—and all of them, poetry for the soul. For me, these first two answers have special resonance. From the first, we learn that a mortal human can be in relationship with Eternity. From the second, we learn to gauge the meaning of our lives in a framework far longer than one lifespan.
Be part of something grand. Be partners with the Eternal.
